On CNN this morning, a member of the Southern Baptist Convention (possibly its leader Frank Page, but I’m not sure), argued that voting to allow gays into the Boy Scouts - a vote that was supposed to be happening today, and has just been postponed until May - is a mater of discriminating against those who hold firm to a faith.
I don’t think something so silly has frustrated me so much, and I am not even American.
The Boy Scouts of America not only want it to seriously be a matter of popular vote wither or not one young boy should have the opportunity to experience the same kind of formative-years character-building as another young boy simply because of who he likes.
Which I would imagine is not the business of the BSA in the first place.
And to Richard Land, whose big appeal to fear is that the BSA will suddenly become dens of pederasty if they don’t tighten the reins: really? Because if that’s what you’re worried about, then it means the BSA has all sorts of other problems, and still none of them are gay Scouts. Also, you have problems. Also, gay Scouts still aren’t one.
It’s hard, if you can remember your childhood in particular, to be given a chance to be a part of a community of peers learning subtly to be better young people - and therefore even better adults. I mean, what is the Boy Scouts about if not character building? And gays have character too.
What young LGBT persons want and need is not only the same chances to be powerful young people, but chances to be reminded that nothing is wrong with them and that they don’t deserve to be treated like shit from society. The BSA could very well be that space, and should be.
I would hate to think, after all, that the solution is to create competition for the BSA - people who actually stand up for their mission statement - all of it, not just the God part; or are the irreligious cast out as well? - instead of bowing to religious pressure.
In fact, what if we were to imagine competition for the BSA - I don’t really care what we call it, but give them something powerful, something that inspires its members to stand up for themselves and others, like The Young Guards or something, I’m terrible at naming. Let it take anyone and everyone. Let it be open to LGBT persons - and let us definitely not forget the T, please. Let it be not pinned down by one religion or another, be accepting of kids of all faiths - and none - and make concessions for them all. Let their Law also say “A Guard is Accepting. A Guard is Respectful. A Guard is Considerate.”
Because if the BSA won’t be, maybe it’s not the place you want to send your son to learn life lessons anyway.
Maybe we can just make this happen instead?